Why do people commit suicide?

Gardener
Posts: 110
Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2026 8:08 pm

I have been suffering from suicidal thoughts recently. I am suffering from financial problems, and I think that majority of the people commit suicide due to financial issues. Many people commit suicide due to problems in relationship. Both of these problems are the major reasons why many people commit suicide. What do you think?
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

User avatar
Jason
Site Admin
Posts: 973
Joined: Sun Dec 21, 2025 8:56 pm
Contact:

Gardener wrote: Fri Jan 16, 2026 12:42 pm I have been suffering from suicidal thoughts recently. I am suffering from financial problems, and I think that majority of the people commit suicide due to financial issues. Many people commit suicide due to problems in relationship. Both of these problems are the major reasons why many people commit suicide. What do you think?
I know in some instances sad emotions become too much. For instance, Judas in the Bible hung himself over guilt etc .
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

Gardener
Posts: 110
Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2026 8:08 pm

Jason wrote: Fri Jan 16, 2026 2:27 pm
Gardener wrote: Fri Jan 16, 2026 12:42 pm I have been suffering from suicidal thoughts recently. I am suffering from financial problems, and I think that majority of the people commit suicide due to financial issues. Many people commit suicide due to problems in relationship. Both of these problems are the major reasons why many people commit suicide. What do you think?
I know in some instances sad emotions become too much. For instance, Judas in the Bible hung himself over guilt etc .
Sad emotions can become overwhelmingly difficulty to deal with. However, in many cases, sad emotions alone might not be the only factor that leads people to commit suicide. Sometimes financial burden and societal pressure can also kead a person to commit suicide.
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

User avatar
Stoic
Posts: 71
Joined: Wed Jul 22, 2026 6:35 am

It is a specific state of mine where judgement is clouded by emotions. Stoics warned people about this. You have a hard time dealing with illness if you failed to stop the cause. I don't call suicide thoughts an illness, it's just a metaphor. I tried commiting suicide twice in my life and 2nd time was almost fatal. This made me realize how foolish the idea was.

However, I must state that sometime I can understand people who do it if there is a "valid" reason for it. If I would to experience horrible torture of my wife, children in front of me, let's say for a long period of time and I would be left in life, that would be so hard to deal with that ending the pain seems very reasonable.

To sum up, I am against it and I think that people should master their emotions and stop them when they appear rather than letting it grow. But in extreme cases of suffering, I would understand.
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

User avatar
Jason
Site Admin
Posts: 973
Joined: Sun Dec 21, 2025 8:56 pm
Contact:

Stoic wrote: Tue Jul 28, 2026 9:42 am It is a specific state of mine where judgement is clouded by emotions. Stoics warned people about this. You have a hard time dealing with illness if you failed to stop the cause. I don't call suicide thoughts an illness, it's just a metaphor. I tried commiting suicide twice in my life and 2nd time was almost fatal. This made me realize how foolish the idea was.

However, I must state that sometime I can understand people who do it if there is a "valid" reason for it. If I would to experience horrible torture of my wife, children in front of me, let's say for a long period of time and I would be left in life, that would be so hard to deal with that ending the pain seems very reasonable.

To sum up, I am against it and I think that people should master their emotions and stop them when they appear rather than letting it grow. But in extreme cases of suffering, I would understand.
God has kept me suicide lately, but others survive these thoughts without it. I guess with those people it's hit and miss.

And definitely it's a dark cloud and there's no reasoning with it, like telling yourself to snap out of it cause of shame or something.
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

User avatar
Stoic
Posts: 71
Joined: Wed Jul 22, 2026 6:35 am

Jason wrote: Tue Jul 28, 2026 4:15 pm
Stoic wrote: Tue Jul 28, 2026 9:42 am It is a specific state of mine where judgement is clouded by emotions. Stoics warned people about this. You have a hard time dealing with illness if you failed to stop the cause. I don't call suicide thoughts an illness, it's just a metaphor. I tried commiting suicide twice in my life and 2nd time was almost fatal. This made me realize how foolish the idea was.

However, I must state that sometime I can understand people who do it if there is a "valid" reason for it. If I would to experience horrible torture of my wife, children in front of me, let's say for a long period of time and I would be left in life, that would be so hard to deal with that ending the pain seems very reasonable.

To sum up, I am against it and I think that people should master their emotions and stop them when they appear rather than letting it grow. But in extreme cases of suffering, I would understand.
God has kept me suicide lately, but others survive these thoughts without it. I guess with those people it's hit and miss.

And definitely it's a dark cloud and there's no reasoning with it, like telling yourself to snap out of it cause of shame or something.
People who never experienced these moments often say: Snap out of it, you can do it, do something physical but the problem is much, much deeper. The core idea all humans wrestle in life is our purpose and if we feel that there is no purpose left, why would i go to gym? How is making me want to live? It is a very serious thing and those people need a true friend next to them, somebody to invest emotionally and time wise. It's not easy and many people find it hard and it also requires tactical approach because you don't want that person to become too dependent on you because his new purpose of life is closely tied to you.
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

User avatar
Jason
Site Admin
Posts: 973
Joined: Sun Dec 21, 2025 8:56 pm
Contact:

Stoic wrote: Thu Jul 30, 2026 9:23 am
Jason wrote: Tue Jul 28, 2026 4:15 pm
Stoic wrote: Tue Jul 28, 2026 9:42 am It is a specific state of mine where judgement is clouded by emotions. Stoics warned people about this. You have a hard time dealing with illness if you failed to stop the cause. I don't call suicide thoughts an illness, it's just a metaphor. I tried commiting suicide twice in my life and 2nd time was almost fatal. This made me realize how foolish the idea was.

However, I must state that sometime I can understand people who do it if there is a "valid" reason for it. If I would to experience horrible torture of my wife, children in front of me, let's say for a long period of time and I would be left in life, that would be so hard to deal with that ending the pain seems very reasonable.

To sum up, I am against it and I think that people should master their emotions and stop them when they appear rather than letting it grow. But in extreme cases of suffering, I would understand.
God has kept me suicide lately, but others survive these thoughts without it. I guess with those people it's hit and miss.

And definitely it's a dark cloud and there's no reasoning with it, like telling yourself to snap out of it cause of shame or something.
People who never experienced these moments often say: Snap out of it, you can do it, do something physical but the problem is much, much deeper. The core idea all humans wrestle in life is our purpose and if we feel that there is no purpose left, why would i go to gym? How is making me want to live? It is a very serious thing and those people need a true friend next to them, somebody to invest emotionally and time wise. It's not easy and many people find it hard and it also requires tactical approach because you don't want that person to become too dependent on you because his new purpose of life is closely tied to you.
For Christians, that friend should be God.
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

User avatar
Stoic
Posts: 71
Joined: Wed Jul 22, 2026 6:35 am

I don't like that concept because God is abstract, not present. You can whisper prayers and nothing is returned. You have to BELIEVE somebody is listening to you. But I think that people NEED hug, shoulder to cry on, understanding. Those things physically trigger our body to react.
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

User avatar
Jason
Site Admin
Posts: 973
Joined: Sun Dec 21, 2025 8:56 pm
Contact:

Stoic wrote: Fri Jul 31, 2026 9:54 am I don't like that concept because God is abstract, not present. You can whisper prayers and nothing is returned. You have to BELIEVE somebody is listening to you. But I think that people NEED hug, shoulder to cry on, understanding. Those things physically trigger our body to react.
Not according to what the Bible says.
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

User avatar
Stoic
Posts: 71
Joined: Wed Jul 22, 2026 6:35 am

Well, I am more empirical based guy, not fantasy. I hear enough stories of people being kidnapped, tortured, disabled and some died, some survived. Was God helping only one of them while others died in the process? or he has nothing to do with it regardless of their prayers.
 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

Post Reply