What might be major opposing arguments to Christianity?
I know that people use argument that God is not as loving as described by believers. In the old testament, he is very brutal, genocidal, orders israelis to kill man, women and children, kills all humans on the Earth (except few chosen ones who obey him), kills babies in the Egypt bcs of the sins of their parents. Those obvious arguments are good enough for me to say that God is everything but loving.
I think that humans are more loving than he is. Take average human and show him a man who commited some serious crime. Would an average human punish only a bad guy or his whole family? Surely only the bad guy, because family had nothing to do with it. But God is very vengeful.
I think that humans are more loving than he is. Take average human and show him a man who commited some serious crime. Would an average human punish only a bad guy or his whole family? Surely only the bad guy, because family had nothing to do with it. But God is very vengeful.
I was doing some deep thinking about this today. Well, it came to me that some must be taken out before they take out themselves (ex. nuclear war). And I'm thinking kids etc., sadly, get caught in the crossfire. But in the Book of Mormon, it tells how young children and babies, at the least, are innocent and are in Paradise.Stoic wrote: Thu Jul 23, 2026 6:30 am I know that people use argument that God is not as loving as described by believers. In the old testament, he is very brutal, genocidal, orders israelis to kill man, women and children, kills all humans on the Earth (except few chosen ones who obey him), kills babies in the Egypt bcs of the sins of their parents. Those obvious arguments are good enough for me to say that God is everything but loving.
I think that humans are more loving than he is. Take average human and show him a man who commited some serious crime. Would an average human punish only a bad guy or his whole family? Surely only the bad guy, because family had nothing to do with it. But God is very vengeful.
However, the all loving God would not harm in such way his own creation. We either accept that he is not all loving but cruel and demanding to be praised in a specific way or continue defending him even though logic points out that something is wrong in his actions. One can say "Well, he is the maker, he can do whatever he wants" . Okay, sure, but then again, we can't say he is all loving because he isn't. And it sounds a bit hypocritical. He will judge us based on our deeds and who will judge him for his?Jason wrote: Thu Jul 23, 2026 7:56 pmI was doing some deep thinking about this today. Well, it came to me that some must be taken out before they take out themselves (ex. nuclear war). And I'm thinking kids etc., sadly, get caught in the crossfire. But in the Book of Mormon, it tells how young children and babies, at the least, are innocent and are in Paradise.Stoic wrote: Thu Jul 23, 2026 6:30 am I know that people use argument that God is not as loving as described by believers. In the old testament, he is very brutal, genocidal, orders israelis to kill man, women and children, kills all humans on the Earth (except few chosen ones who obey him), kills babies in the Egypt bcs of the sins of their parents. Those obvious arguments are good enough for me to say that God is everything but loving.
I think that humans are more loving than he is. Take average human and show him a man who commited some serious crime. Would an average human punish only a bad guy or his whole family? Surely only the bad guy, because family had nothing to do with it. But God is very vengeful.
Humans give birth to their children and they love them. Even if the kid does something horrible, they still love him and wouldn't kill it like God does to thousands. Could it be that humans are more humane than the God?
The groups God has targeted throughout the Bible were warned, and based on what's recorded, it seems like most did not heed it. I do know the people of Nineveh repented.Stoic wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 12:10 pmHowever, the all loving God would not harm in such way his own creation. We either accept that he is not all loving but cruel and demanding to be praised in a specific way or continue defending him even though logic points out that something is wrong in his actions. One can say "Well, he is the maker, he can do whatever he wants" . Okay, sure, but then again, we can't say he is all loving because he isn't. And it sounds a bit hypocritical. He will judge us based on our deeds and who will judge him for his?Jason wrote: Thu Jul 23, 2026 7:56 pmI was doing some deep thinking about this today. Well, it came to me that some must be taken out before they take out themselves (ex. nuclear war). And I'm thinking kids etc., sadly, get caught in the crossfire. But in the Book of Mormon, it tells how young children and babies, at the least, are innocent and are in Paradise.Stoic wrote: Thu Jul 23, 2026 6:30 am I know that people use argument that God is not as loving as described by believers. In the old testament, he is very brutal, genocidal, orders israelis to kill man, women and children, kills all humans on the Earth (except few chosen ones who obey him), kills babies in the Egypt bcs of the sins of their parents. Those obvious arguments are good enough for me to say that God is everything but loving.
I think that humans are more loving than he is. Take average human and show him a man who commited some serious crime. Would an average human punish only a bad guy or his whole family? Surely only the bad guy, because family had nothing to do with it. But God is very vengeful.
Humans give birth to their children and they love them. Even if the kid does something horrible, they still love him and wouldn't kill it like God does to thousands. Could it be that humans are more humane than the God?
And God operates according to certain rules, I'm guessing ones that are unavoidable, so this leads to collateral damage.
If God is the omnipotent being, how can there be collateral damage? If he can make the sea split in two, why can't he somehow save innocent? I think there is even a verse in which God strictly commands to kill all men, women and kids they find in a city. xDJason wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 3:38 pmThe groups God has targeted throughout the Bible were warned, and based on what's recorded, it seems like most did not heed it. I do know the people of Nineveh repented.Stoic wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 12:10 pmHowever, the all loving God would not harm in such way his own creation. We either accept that he is not all loving but cruel and demanding to be praised in a specific way or continue defending him even though logic points out that something is wrong in his actions. One can say "Well, he is the maker, he can do whatever he wants" . Okay, sure, but then again, we can't say he is all loving because he isn't. And it sounds a bit hypocritical. He will judge us based on our deeds and who will judge him for his?Jason wrote: Thu Jul 23, 2026 7:56 pm
I was doing some deep thinking about this today. Well, it came to me that some must be taken out before they take out themselves (ex. nuclear war). And I'm thinking kids etc., sadly, get caught in the crossfire. But in the Book of Mormon, it tells how young children and babies, at the least, are innocent and are in Paradise.
Humans give birth to their children and they love them. Even if the kid does something horrible, they still love him and wouldn't kill it like God does to thousands. Could it be that humans are more humane than the God?
And God operates according to certain rules, I'm guessing ones that are unavoidable, so this leads to collateral damage.
He's bound by certain rules. For instance, how can God possibly eliminate all evil, without infringing on human freedom?Stoic wrote: Sun Jul 26, 2026 9:56 amIf God is the omnipotent being, how can there be collateral damage? If he can make the sea split in two, why can't he somehow save innocent? I think there is even a verse in which God strictly commands to kill all men, women and kids they find in a city. xDJason wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 3:38 pmThe groups God has targeted throughout the Bible were warned, and based on what's recorded, it seems like most did not heed it. I do know the people of Nineveh repented.Stoic wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 12:10 pm
However, the all loving God would not harm in such way his own creation. We either accept that he is not all loving but cruel and demanding to be praised in a specific way or continue defending him even though logic points out that something is wrong in his actions. One can say "Well, he is the maker, he can do whatever he wants" . Okay, sure, but then again, we can't say he is all loving because he isn't. And it sounds a bit hypocritical. He will judge us based on our deeds and who will judge him for his?
Humans give birth to their children and they love them. Even if the kid does something horrible, they still love him and wouldn't kill it like God does to thousands. Could it be that humans are more humane than the God?
And God operates according to certain rules, I'm guessing ones that are unavoidable, so this leads to collateral damage.
How can God create something which is influenced by evil, which can be corrupted in its own nature? For example, God promises creation of "new heart" at the end of time for those who are chosen. If he can make those people unable to sin in heaven, why he didn't do that right away? Why would generations of humans suffer because of the mistake 2 people make? I think that is rather cruel.Jason wrote: Sun Jul 26, 2026 3:41 pmHe's bound by certain rules. For instance, how can God possibly eliminate all evil, without infringing on human freedom?Stoic wrote: Sun Jul 26, 2026 9:56 amIf God is the omnipotent being, how can there be collateral damage? If he can make the sea split in two, why can't he somehow save innocent? I think there is even a verse in which God strictly commands to kill all men, women and kids they find in a city. xDJason wrote: Fri Jul 24, 2026 3:38 pm
The groups God has targeted throughout the Bible were warned, and based on what's recorded, it seems like most did not heed it. I do know the people of Nineveh repented.
And God operates according to certain rules, I'm guessing ones that are unavoidable, so this leads to collateral damage.
If your son/daughter would sin against you and you had the power to punish their children and children of their children, would you? From a human perspective, is it fair in the first place?
The existence of evil is simply the price of freedom, the other option being the creation of robots. But, thinking even deeper, I don't think it was even possible for God to create "righteous robots".Stoic wrote: Tue Jul 28, 2026 9:37 amHow can God create something which is influenced by evil, which can be corrupted in its own nature? For example, God promises creation of "new heart" at the end of time for those who are chosen. If he can make those people unable to sin in heaven, why he didn't do that right away? Why would generations of humans suffer because of the mistake 2 people make? I think that is rather cruel.Jason wrote: Sun Jul 26, 2026 3:41 pmHe's bound by certain rules. For instance, how can God possibly eliminate all evil, without infringing on human freedom?Stoic wrote: Sun Jul 26, 2026 9:56 am
If God is the omnipotent being, how can there be collateral damage? If he can make the sea split in two, why can't he somehow save innocent? I think there is even a verse in which God strictly commands to kill all men, women and kids they find in a city. xD
If your son/daughter would sin against you and you had the power to punish their children and children of their children, would you? From a human perspective, is it fair in the first place?
